Corning Glass Works v. Brennan 1974

views updated

Corning Glass Works v. Brennan 1974

Petitioner: Corning Glass Works

Respondent: Peter J. Brennan, U.S. Secretary of Labor

Petitioner's Claim: That the Court of Appeals erred by ruling that Corning violated the Equal Pay Act.

Chief Lawyer for Petitioner: Scott F. Zimmerman

Chief Lawyer for Respondent: Allan Abbot Tuttle

Justices for the Court: William J. Brennan, Jr., William O. Douglas, Thurgood Marshall (writing for the Court), Lewis F. Powell, Jr., Byron R. White

Justices Dissenting: Harry A. Blackmun, Warren E. Burger, William H. Rehnquist (Potter Stewart did not participate)

Date of Decision: June 3, 1974

Decision: The Supreme Court said Corning violated the Equal Pay Act by paying male nightshift inspection workers higher wages than female dayshift inspection workers.

Significance: With Corning, the Supreme Court reinforced the policy of "equal pay for equal work."

Corning Glass Works was a company with production plants in Corning, New York, and Wellsboro, Pennsylvania. Prior to 1925, Corning operated its Wellsboro plant only during the day. The employees who inspected finished products were all female.

Between 1925 and 1930, Corning began to use automatic production equipment, which made finished products faster than people made them. It became necessary for Corning to hire nightshift inspectors to keep up with the increased production. Corning, however, had two problems. Under New York and Pennsylvania law, women were not allowed to work at night. In addition, men thought inspection work was inferior work for women. Men would not do inspection work unless they got more money than female inspectors received. Corning gave the male nightshift inspectors more money.

Fair Labor Standards

In 1963, Congress passed the Equal Pay Act. The law required companies to pay men and women equally for similar work. By then, New York and Pennsylvania had gotten rid of the laws that prevented women from working at night.

In June 1966, Corning began to allow women to get the higher paying nightshift inspection jobs. Then in January 1969, Corning signed an agreement to pay dayshift and nightshift inspectors the same money. The agreement, however, contained an exception for nightshift workers hired before January 1969. Those workers, most of whom were men, still received higher pay than dayshift inspectors.

The U.S. Secretary of Labor filed two lawsuits against Corning, one in federal court in New York and one in Pennsylvania. The Secretary charged Corning with violating the Equal Pay Act by paying male nightshift inspectors higher wages than female dayshift inspectors. The Secretary said Corning could not fix the problem just by opening up nightshift jobs for women. He wanted Corning to give raises to the dayshift inspectors to make their wages equal to those of the nightshift inspectors.

Corning fought the lawsuit. The Equal Pay Act said companies could pay different wages for people working under different "working conditions." Corning said it paid nightshift workers more because working at night was less desirable. After trials and appeals, the federal court of appeals in New York ruled in favor of the United States while the one in Pennsylvania ruled in favor of Corning. The U.S. Supreme Court decided to review both cases.

THURGOOD MARSHALL

Thurgood Marshall was born on July 2, 1908 in Baltimore, Maryland. The son of a schoolteacher and club steward, Marshall left Baltimore in 1926 to attend the all-black Lincoln University. When Marshall tried to get into law school at the University of Maryland, the school turned him down because he was African American. Marshall attended law school at Howard University in Washington, D.C., where he graduated first in his class.

Marshall practiced law in Baltimore from 1933 to 1938. There he fought for civil rights by working as counsel for the Baltimore branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People ("NAACP"). In 1939, Marshall became director of the NAACP's Legal Defense and Education Fund. In that role, Marshall argued and won many important civil rights cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. His most important case, Brown v. Board of Education (1954), ended segregation, the practice of separating black and white students in different public schools.

In 1961, President John F. Kennedy nominated Marshall to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Southern opposition to Marshall's appointment delayed it for one year. In 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson appointed Marshall to be U.S. Solicitor General, the attorney who represents the United States in federal court. Two years later President Johnson chose Marshall to be the first African American justice on the U.S. Supreme Court. Many southern senators again opposed Marshall's nomination and again were defeated. During his twenty-five years on the Supreme Court, Marshall regularly voted in favor of individual civil and constitutional rights.

Equal Pay for Equal Work

With a 5–3 decision, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Secretary of Labor. Justice Thurgood Marshall delivered the Court's opinion. Marshall said Congress passed the Equal Pay Act to end the notion that men, because of their role in society, should get paid more than women for the same work. "Equal work should be rewarded by equal wages."

The problem, of course, was deciding whether nightshift and dayshift inspection was equal work. The Supreme Court said it was. Inspectors at night had the same surroundings and same hazards as inspectors during the day.

Marshall emphasized that Corning was free to pay nightshift workers more if working at night had added psychological or physical demands. Corning, however, had not proved that those demands existed. Its pay differential was a relic of the days when men were paid more because they were men. That was illegal sex discrimination under the Equal Pay Act. Corning would have to raise the pay rates for dayshift inspection workers.